COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
V.
MARBOAH

(1962) JELR 69557 (HC)    
High Court  ·  10 Dec 1962 ·  Ghana
 · 
Other Citations
[1962] 2 GLR 159
CORAM
APALOO J.
Core Terms Beta
accused
conclusion
court
prosecution
a.c.
apaloo
apaloo j.
attorney-general
case
case of makin v
character
circumstances
commissioner of police v
conviction
criminal acts
criminal conduct
evidence
finding
indictment
learned circuit judge
marboah
new south wales
offence
order
part of their case
person
prejudicial evidence
previous convictions
principles of criminal justice
purpose
statement of the accused

APALOO J.: As long ago as 1894, it was stated in the case of Makin v. Attorney-General for New South Wales [1894] A.C. 57 at p. 65 that “it is undoubtedly not competent for the prosecution to adduce evidence tending to shew that the accused had been guilty of criminal acts other than those covered by the indictment, for the purpose of leading to a conclusion that the accused is a person likely from his criminal conduct or character to have committed the offence for which he is being tried.” The prosecution in recording a statement of the accused’s previous convictions and submitting it to the court as part of their case have indubitably offended against what I would call one of the most deeply rooted and jealously guarded principles of criminal justice. In a case which is admittedly wholly circumstantial, I find it impossible to say that if this highly prejudicial evidence had not been communicated to the court, the learned circuit judge would have inevitably come to the same conclusi…

There's more. Sign in to continue reading.

judy.legal is the comprehensive database of case law and legislation from Ghana, Kenya and Nigeria. Gain seamless access to over 20,000 cases, recent judgments, statutes, and rules of court.

Get started   Login