JUDGMENT
Mohamed Halane Abdi (hereinafter called “the appellant”) was convicted of the murder of Dr Vasantral Nathalal Mehta ( the deceased) and sentenced to death. It was alleged that on 20th August, 1985, between 10.00 and 11.00 a.m he of malice aforethought caused the death of the deceased in his medical clinic on Kenyatta Avenue Mombasa by shooting him.
As the actual shooting occurred in a room in which there was no one else except the appellant and the deceased, there is very little direct evidence as to what actually happened. The witness who was closest, was the deceased’s attendant, one Karisa Yaa, but he too was sitting in the next room from where he could not see either the participants or observe the events. His evidence was that on the fateful day, the appellant arrived at the clinic at about 9.00 a.m. but as the deceased was then busy with his consultations, he left and returned about an hour later. Upon his return he was admitted into the deceased’s Consulting room apparen…