MUSA DATTIJO MUHAMMAD, J.C.A (Delivering the Leading Judgment): On 17/9/2011, I allowed this appeal and remitted the case back to the tribunal wherefrom the appeal emanated for the case to be heard and determined on its merits. I deferred my reasons for the decision to a date to be communicated to the parties subsequently. I now state my reasons for that decision. Before doing so, let me however recount very briefly the facts of the case on which the appeal is predicated.
By their petition dated and filed on 17th May, 2011, the appellants challenged the return of the 1st respondent by the 2nd-5th respondents as the winner of the 26th April, 2011 House of Assembly Election for the Obio/Akpor constituency 1 in River state. Whereas the petition was served on the 2nd-5th respondents on the 23rd May, 2011, the 1st respondent had the petition served on him on 8th June, 2011. Although the two sets of respondents filed their respective replies to the petition on the same day, 13th June 2011, …