Customer Support

COMMISSIONER OF POLICE
V.
ROBERT OGBAME COFIE

JELR 86585 (WACA)

West Africa Court of Appeal West Africa [For WACA cases]
BriefBot icon

BriefBot Summary

Free

Get an AI-generated summary of this case.

Case Details

Judges:COR. KINGDON AND PETRIDES, C.JJ., AND M’CARTHY, J.
Counsel:W. H. Irwin for Respondent. C. P. F. A.woonor-Renner for Appellant.
Other Citations:1941 7 WACA 179-180

 KINGDON, C.J., NIGERIA, PETRIDES, C.,T., GOLD COAST AND M’CARTHY, J. In this case the appellant was convicted by the District Magistrate, Accra, of stealing two shirts from the King's ware- house. The only difficulty in the case is that the prosecution did not give evidence to prove that the two shirts which formed the subject matter of the charge were found to be missing from any bale of goods in the King’s Warehouse, though evidence was given that a bale of similar shirts had been tampered with. No satisfactory explanation has been given as to why the contents of the bale were not checked, so that evidence could have been led to prove the loss. But it is well established that the fact of stealing may be proved by all the circumstances of the case and it is not a rule of law that the corpus delicti must be expressly proved.

It is always a question for the Jury or other Judge of the facts (R. v. Dredge 1 Cox 235; R. v. Hooper, 175 Eng. Rep. 637; R. v. B1trton, 23 L.J .M.C. 52; R. v. Sbarra, 13 Cr. App. Rep. 118; R. v. Fuschillo: 27. Cr. App. Rep. 193; R. v. Boateng (unreported) decided in this Court on the 10th June, 1941).

In this case the evidence against the appellant is so over- whelming that, in spite of the failure of the prosecution to lead evidence as to the corpus delicti, we are of opinion that the conviction must be allowed to stand.

The appeal is dismissed.

There's more. Sign in to continue reading.

judy.legal is the comprehensive database of case law and legislation from Ghana, Kenya and Nigeria. Gain seamless access to over 77,000 cases, recent judgments, statutes, and rules of court.