Customer Support

GBOLADE
V.
OLADEJO

(1994) JELR 80008 (CA)

Court of Appeal 2 Jun 1994 Nigeria
BriefBot icon

BriefBot Summary

Sign in to read the AI-generated summary of this case.

Sign in to read

Case Details

Judges:ALOMA MARIAM MUKHTAR, J.C.A. (Presided), GEORGE ADESOLA OGUNTADE, J.C.A. (Read the Leading Judgment), ISA AYO SALAMI, J.C.A. (Dissented)
Counsel:A.O Olutunfese, Esq. - for the Appellant M.L. Lagunju, Esq. - for the Respondent OGUNTADE, J.C.A., (Delivering the Leading Judgment): The respondentwas the plaintiff before the Ibadan High Court (Coram: Kolawole J) where he claimed against two defendants (of whom the appellant was the 2nd defendant) for N l00,000.00 jointly and severally being special and general damages for: ''the 1st defendant's negligence when on or about 12th April, 1985, he the 2nd defendant's driver and servant negligently drove his commercial bus with registration No. OG6193JA along Ijebu-Ode Road. Mamu. Ibadan and collided with the plaintiff a motor cyclist riding his motor cycle No. OY 237 DY and caused him severe injuries, pains and shock." Pleadings were filed and exchanged between the plaintiff and the 2nd defendant. The 1st defendant did not file a statement of defence. Kolawole J. tried the suit. On 19th June, 1987, judgment was delivered. The trial judge found that the plaintiff was contributorily negligent and awarded N20,726.30 in plaintiff's favour for the negligence of 1st defendant for which the 2nd defendant was found vicariously liable. The 2nd defendant has brought this appeal against the said judgment. In his notice of appeal filed on 15-9-87. the 2nd defendant raised four grounds of appeal. He later sought and was granted leave to file additional grounds of appeal. In the amended appellant's brief filed, the appellant indicated that he was abandoning all the four original grounds of appeal. The issues for determination were formulated thus: "I. Was the negligence of 1st and 2nd defendants decided on facts specifically pleaded by the plaintiff. 2.If the answer to question I is in the negative, it follows that plaintiff has not proved the issue of negligence plaintiff brought to court and his case must fail for parties are bound by their pleadings and any evidence which is at variance with their pleadings goes to no issue and should have been disregarded by the court. 3.Was the 2nd defendant vicariously liable for the negligence of the 1st defendant. 4.Was the award of N450.00 for loss of use at N30 per month justifiable in law in the calculation of the amount of damages....
Other Citations:(1994) 8 NWLR (Pt. 362) 281

SALAMI, J.C.A. (Dissenting): I have read the judgment of my learned brother Oguntade, J.C.A. and I agree with his analysis of the law touching upon applicability of the principles of res ipsa loquitur and quantum of damages. I do not have anything further to add except to adopt them as mine.

However, on the question of negligence I am unable to accept that the plaintiff and not the defendant was negligent. I am therefore respectfully dissenting solely on the question of liability for negligence.

In paragraphs 4(a) - (f) of the amended statement of claim the plaintiff pleaded the particulars of negligence he relied upon as follows -

"Particulars of negligence

(a)Driving at an excessive speed.

(b)Driving unto the wrong side of the road and thereby colliding with the plaintiff when the plaintiff had completely kept on his right side of the road.

(c)Failing to keep any or proper look-out or to have any sufficient regard for other traffic, particularly on-coming traffic on the said road.

(d)Overt…

There's more. Sign in to continue reading.

judy.legal is the comprehensive database of case law and legislation from Ghana, Kenya and Nigeria. Gain seamless access to over 77,000 cases, recent judgments, statutes, and rules of court.