Customer Support

H. M. DARKO
V.
AGYAKWA

JELR 82827 (WACA)

West Africa Court of Appeal West Africa [For WACA cases]
BriefBot icon

BriefBot Summary

Sign in to read the AI-generated summary of this case.

Sign in to read

Case Details

Judges:COR. KINGDON, PETRIDES AND GRAHAM PAUL, C.JJ.
Counsel:E. C. Quist (with him Mr. N. A. Ollennu) for Appellant. Akilagpa Sawyerr for Respondent.
Other Citations:1943 9 WACA 163-167

KINGDON. C.J., NIGERIA, PETRIDES, C.J., GOLD COAST AND GRAHAM PAUL, C.J., SIERRA LEONE. (Read by Petridies, C.J., Gold Coast). The plaintiff commenced these proceedings in the Tribunal of Omanhene of Akyem Abuakwa on the 5th February, 1942, claiming-

(a) Declaration of title to all that piece or parcel of land with cocoa farm thereon situate lying and being at or Kuaho and bounded on the North by H.M. Darko’s property, South by Agyakwa’s property, East by Revd. Asiedu’s property and on the West by Odei’s property which cocoa farm defendant claims to be his and has cultivated part of the plaintiff’s forest land situated directly before the said cocoa farm. (b) £25 damages from defendant for trespass committed on the said land. (c) Accounts from 1939-41.

The claim was, in effect, that defendant, who admittedly owned land to the south of plaintiff’s land, had encroached on the plaintiff’s cocoa farm and forest to the north of defendant’s land.

There is no properly orientated plan in this case and the evidence as to the compass bearings is too uncertain for us to know definitely how the land is orientated and in using the terms “north” and “south” we do so only for convenience of reference, calling the River Kua side of the rough sketch plan (Exhibit “E” ) the “ south” . The same reservation applies to our use of the words “east” and “ west”.

Plaintiff's case was that about 1913 he and three of his brothers, namely, Johnson Agyiri, Kwadjo Agyiri and the Reverend Asiedu purchased a piece of forest land at Adimadim or Kuaho and shared it in proportion to the amount that each had contributed towards the purchase price, but there is no evidence as to what those amounts were. The area of the land purchased was 60 by 30 ropes and the purchase price £60. Although the plaintiff in his evidence stated that he and Kwadjo Agyiri took the east part of the land and Johnson Agyiri and the Reverend Asiedu ,the west part, it appears probable from the evidence as a whole that he really meant that he and Kwadjo Agyiri got what we call the north portion and Johnson Agyiri and the Revcrend Asiedu what we call the south portion, but it is impossible on the evidence to place with any accuracy the boundaries either of the land originally bought by the four brothers or of the respective portions obtained by the three children of the deceased Johnson Agyiri when his portion was divided. “Ropes” are only linear measures and not sufficient to define a superficial area.

In 1928 Johnson Agyiri died and the plaintiff, as his successor, divided the portion of Johnson Agyiri among the three children of the latter. The names of these three children were Ben Asiedu. Opanin Asiedu and Ya Ayaw. Ben Asiedu mortgaged his portion to Osei who on non-payment of the mortgage debt foreclosed. The right title and interest of Ben Asiedu in the property was sold and the defendant purchased it.

At the trial the plaintiff gave evidence and called Ben Asiedu only as a witness. The defendant having called his witnesses the Tribunal appointed certain Councillors and the Tribunal Clerk to view the land in dispute and submit their report. After their report had been received the Tribunal gave judgment. The last paragraph of that judgment is as follows;- “The Tribunal is therefore not convinced by defendant’s evidence “purporting the sale of the forest including the farms belonging to “Ya Ayaw and Opanin Asiedu and therefore gives judgment in favour “of the plaintiff with costs to be taxed. Farms belonging to Ya Ayaw “and Opanin Asiedu should be excluded accordingly. Plaintiff to “possess the forest land.”

From this judgment the defendant appealed to the Provincial Commissioner’s Court, Eastern Province. That Court held that as the appellant had not paid or deposited the costs awarded by the Tribunal the appeal was not properly before the Court and dismissed the appeal.

On appeal, this Court in its order of the 18th June, 1943, held that the Provincial Commissioner’s Court was right in dismissing the appeal but decided, in exercise of the discretion given to it under section 82 (2) of the Native Administration Ordinance (Cap. 76) for the purpose of doing substantial justice between the parties, to hear the appeal. The area of land purchased by the four brothers was according to the plaintiff 60 by 30 ropes. When this land was distributed the Revd. Asiedu was allotted 12 ropes and Johnson Agyiri 18 ropes both areas being on the south part of the land. It would seem that the part that was allotted to the plaintiff and Kwadjo Agyiri was the remaining portion which lay to the north of that allotted to Johnson Agyiri and the Revd. Asiedu.

The Committee of Inspection did their work very thoroughly. They made a plan of the land in dispute. This plan is not according to scale and has no compass points shown. For these reasons it is difficult to follow, and also for the reason that it apparently shows the contentions of each party, without a clear indication as to which is which and this has to be ascertained more or less by guess work.

According to the report the committee measured the whole land in dispute and found the land sold to the defendant was 11 ropes and 23 fathoms in length and 8 ropes in breadth. The Tribunal appears to have overlooked this finding and to have assumed that the Committee of Inspection had found that the portions marked Yah Yao and Opanin Asiedu (south of Yah Yao) were in the position shown on the plan, whereas this was only the plaintiffs contention as to their position and it is certainly doubtful on the evidence if this contention is correct. The committee found that the forest was 2 ropes and 6 fathoms long and 2 ropes 5 fathoms broad. At each of the four corners of the land the committee found buried an empty bottle which according to the defendant indicated his boundaries.

Seeing that the plaintiff was seeking a declaration of title to the land in dispute it is clear that the onus of proof lay on him. It will be seen from the portion of the judgment of the Tribunal quoted above that this was not appreciated by the Tribunal and that they gave judgment for the plaintiff because they were not convinced by the defendant’s evidence. It follows that for this reason alone the judgment of the Tribunal cannot be upheld.

The Certificate of Purchase on which the defendant relies is dated the 3rd July, 1939. The defendant went into possession and plucked cocoa. It is in respect of this cocoa that the plaintiff claims an account from the year 1939.

Looking at the writ and the plaintiff’s evidence it seems to us that the evidence fell far short of what he should have established to entitle him to a declaration of title to any portion of the land he claimed as his. In his writ he states that his land on the south adjoins that of the defendant. This according to the evidence is patently untrue as plaintiff admits that Yah Yao is his neighbour on the south side. Yah Yao was not a party to these proceedings. Not only did the plaintiff seek a declaration of title to land which he admits is hers but also to a portion of land belonging to Opanin Asiedu whose successor, Ben Asiedu, is not a party to this action although he gave evidence in plaintiff’s favour.

Looking at the plan it will be seen that the land which plaintiff contends was allotted to Johnson Agyiri and to which his three children succeeded on the death of their father is very much less in length than the 18 ropes admittedly allotted to Johnson. The defendant acquired title to the land which he claims in 1939. He can be regarded as a stranger to the land. There were two men who could have given most material evidence, namely, the plaintiff’s brothers, the Revd. Asiedu and Kwadjo Agyiri. The 12 rope8 that were allotted to the Revd. Asiedu are probably on the east side of a large portion of the area in dispute, but the evidence as a whole leaves this uncertain. It was obviously the duty of the plaintiff to have called one or both of these brothers, or their representatives as witnesses. They might have been able to explain why the portion allotted to Johnson Agyi~i had shrunk. The only witness the plaintiff called was Ben Asiedu who, according to the plaintiff, had the temerity to start interpleaded proceedings in the plaintiff’s name to defeat a right that Osei had to seize Ren Asiedu’s land.

Defendant’s counsel has contended that inasmuch as plaintiff admitted that Johnson Agyiri’s share 01 the property was 18 ropes and was at the southern end of the property and adjoining on the east the property of the Revd. Asiedu the plaintiff had failed to establish title to any part of the area he claimed and his claim should have been dismissed. We were greatly impressed by this contention. We have however come to the conclusion that we cannot accede to it, since the whole case is so confuse that is it impossible to decide what are the rights and wrongs of it.

In our opinion the justice of the case demands that the plaintiff should be non-suited as his evidence did not justify the grant of a declaration of title but that he should be at liberty to bring a properly conceived fresh action if he should see fit. In that event it will certainly be advisable that a proper plan should be prepared showing all the material points in the case, including the whole area originally purchased by the four brothers, and the respective areas allotted to the three children of Johnson Agyiri.

We allow the appeal and set aside the judgment of the Tribunal and direct that in lieu of the judgment given there shall be entered judgment in the following terms:-

“The plaintiff is non-suited with liberty to bring a fresh “action. The plaintiff to pay the defendant’s taxed cost’s “in the Tribunal.”

The order of the Provincial Commissioner’s Court as to costs in favour of the respondent is his Court stands good. Inasmuch as the respondent ,has succeeded in this Court upon the appeal from the decision of the Provincial Commissioner’s Court but the appellant has succeeded on the merits which he was allowed to argue only by virtue of a special exercise of discretion in his favour, each party will bear his own costs in this Court.

There's more. Sign in to continue reading.

judy.legal is the comprehensive database of case law and legislation from Ghana, Kenya and Nigeria. Gain seamless access to over 77,000 cases, recent judgments, statutes, and rules of court.