JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
1. This is an appeal from the judgment of the High Court (Dulu, J) delivered on 18th March 2011 holding the appellant liable for defamation and awarding the respondent Kshs. 4.5 million in general damages. The main issue in this appeal is whether the learned trial Judge erred in rejecting the defence of fair comment that had been advanced by the appellant.
Background
2. At the material time, the 1st appellant was the publisher of a newspaper, Daily Metro. On 11th February 2008, it published an article in that newspaper under the title, “Dangerous Talk” authored by the 2nd appellant concerning the respondent. At the time, the respondent was the spokesperson of the Government of Kenya. As that article was the basis of the respondent’s claim, it is necessary to reproduce it in its entirety:
"DANGEROUS TALKKenya's King of cheap TALKtakes a turn for worse - careless TALK
WHILE the political fires were being put out everywhere in Kenya this past weekend, hawk Alfred Mutua f…