PEMU JCA (Delivering the Lead Judgment): This is an appeal against the decision of the High Court of Lagos State, Lagos Judicial Division in a Matrimonial Causes Proceedings, presided over by the honourable Justice Moni Fafiade. The judgment of that court was delivered on 14 January 1999, pages 153-175 of the record of appeal.
Synopsis of the facts of the case
The respondent (as petitioner in the lower court) had initially filed a petition for judicial separation against her husband, the appellant, in the present appeal on the grounds of adultery and refusal to consummate the marriage. Later, this was amended to a petition of dissolution of marriage on the same grounds (in 2nd amended reply and answer to petition filed on 4 December 1996). The petitioner in the court below had alleged that the appellant had been having adulterous relationship with one Mrs. Eyitomi Erin Oyedipe, (2nd respondent in the court below), while the appellant and herself were still living together as husband a…