Coussey, J.A. This suit originated in the Native Court 3 of Labadi in the Ga State, although the property in dispute is situate at Horse Road in the Gbese quarter of Ga or Accra: The two plaintiffs, who are respectively the sons of two brothers, Aryee and Ama Sliki, both deceased, claimed for themselves and on behalf of the other children of the two brothers named, a declaration that the house in dispute was the joint property of Aryee and Ama Sliki and that it devolved upon the plain. tiffs on the death of their fathers.
The cause of action stated is that the first defendant had, without authority and contrary to native custom, granted a chamber and hall with verandah in the said house to the second defendant to reside in; that the second defendant had been collecting rents of the house without the authority of the plaintiffs who therefore claimed recovery of possession and an injunction and damages for trespass and unlawful occupation.
After commenting on the oral and documentary evidence the Native Court entered judgment for the plaintiffs, now appellants, in the following terms:- The Court having carefully gone into this matter on its merits comes to conclusion that since defendants were able to satisfy the Court with any substantive facts regarding the acquisition of the land the Court finds that the submission put forward by them is quite futile and frail; the plaintiffs have satisfied the Court with their evidence supported by documents.”
From this judgment the defendants. now respondents, appealed to the Land Court (Jackson, J.) which on the 24th September, 1952. allowed the appeal and set aside the judgment of the Native Court on the grounds that the judgment expressed a complete negation of Ga customary law, and if permitted to stand.. would tend to encourage fictitious and collusive actions designed to defeat the title and interest of the blood members of the family traced through Chicher Djanfiwa and of which the late A. A. Randolph (father of the second defendant) was one.
The Land Court held that, with certain exceptions which did not arise in this case, there is one person only who may maintain an action to establish rights in family property and that is the head of the family. It is against Ga customary law, the Court held, that self-acquired property, upon the death of the owner or owners devolves by descent to their children. Upon the death of the owner, this property became family property in which all members have a joint and indivisible interest. The interest of the children of an owner of self-acquired property amounts to a right of support out of the estate.
From this judgment the plaintiffs have appealed to this Court on several- grounds, but they may be summarised under these two headings:- (1) that an experienced Native Court which understood Ga customary law had held that, as to this particular property, descent. was through males and that it had become the joint property of the plaintiffs for the benefit of their immediate families; (2) that the Judge of the Land Court erroneously ignored (i) a judgment of the Gbese Tribunal dated 23rd September, 1920, and (ii) an arbitration award between the parties dated 28th July, 1943.
Dealing with the documentary evidence, the plaintiffs-appellants have con- tended that the land was purchased by their late fathers Aryee and Ama Sliki who gave the property to the plaintiffs, their children, as property over which they now have sole control and that it is not family property.
In my opinion it is beyond doubt that this is family property. The finding of the Ga Mantse's Tribunal of 5th May, 1928, in Amelia Korkor Tagoe and Others v. Kordua Nye Ayikailey and Others, exhibit “D” , is that Teiko Abonua acquired the land for his wife Chicher Djanfiwa's children Ama Sliki and Aryee.
From the evidence the following tree appears to show the family:-
Teiko Abonua-Chicher Djanfiwa | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | | Aryee Tagoe Armah Sliki=Amelia Tagoe Amane Afua (f) | | | First pltff. …………………. ……………………………………… Ayitey alias | | | | | S. H. Tagoe Second pltff. Lucy Tagoe Akoshia, Wallace A. A. Randolph J. E. Tagoe Matilda Bruce | Bruce Second deft.
Assuming that Aryee Tagoe and Armah Sliki had a joint interest in the property, upon their deaths inheritance is through the uterine descendants of Amane Afua, the daughter of Chicher Djanftwa. With this fact in mind the position of A. A. Randolph becomes apparent.
The judgment of the Gbese Mantse Tribunal dated 23rd September, 1920, ;upon which the plafutiffs-appellants rely; went on appeal to the Provincial Commissioner's Court: exhibit " F ".
In the Court last named, after mutual admissions on the part of the first plaintiff Ayitey and A. A. Randolph, it is recorded that" the Court finds that the land in dispute is the equal divided property of plaintiff and defendant A. A. Randolph ". The expression" equal divided property" is, in my opinion, an error on the part of a Provincial Commissioner who was not versed in the law and who was unaided at the time by learned counsel, With respect, he was endeavouring to express that it was family property. It was in fact family property in which A. A, Randolph had a direct interest. As the learned Judge observed in the judgment now appealed from, " however individuals may have contracted with others out of the native law, it cannot destroy the rights of other persons having hereditable interest in the estate to ask for a declaration as to their rights ".
The declaration in the award of 28th July, 1943. exhibit "C ", to the effect that the house in dispute primarily belonged to the plafutiffs, the children-oI ryee and Armah Sliki, is obviously contrary to the Ga customary law. The object of the award appears to me to be directed to ensure that rents and profits f the property" which in the ordinary course should have been enjoyed jointly y all the principal members of the family", should be used to pay family out- oings and debts instead of being utilised by A. A. Randolph for his sole benent.
It is a relief to find that in 1944 when the plaintiffs sued A. A. Randolph in the Gbese Tribunal, also exhibit " D", they did not sue on this award and that the judgment of the Tribunal makes abundantly clear the family character of e property.
"When pressed before us to reveal the head of the family learned counsel for e plaintiffs-appellants suggested that the two plaintiffs were heads of their nilies and that the children held the property by virtue of the alleged gift ade during their fathers' life time. The children, claimants in Brandford Nettey , The Gold Coast Independent Press and Akai Koft Nettey, claimant, 3 W.A.C.A. 101. were in the same dilemma. It is an untenable position.
The plaintiffs' claim in itself demonstrates that there was no gift inter vivos for ey ask ior'a declaration that upon the death of Aryee and Armah Sliki the roperty has devolved upon them. In my opinion the suit should have been lick out as showing no cause of action. Self-acquired property does not on